Home » Pasta Sauces » Best Store Bought Alfredo Sauce

Best Store Bought Alfredo Sauce


Making your own Alfredo sauce at home takes a lot of time and effort, which is why not many people decide to prepare recipes that make the use of this kind of sauce. However, that can be resolved by going for store-bought mixes and sauces at hand.

Store-bought Alfredo sauce may sometimes taste bland, but many of them really taste great due to having more natural herbs and spices and little to no preservatives at hand. Choosing the right one isn’t easy because different manufacturers have different ways of mixing the ingredients, so they all have their own pros and cons.

Our Product Reviews

Here are some of the best store bought Alfredo sauces that we could find on Amazon:

Bertolli Alfredo Sauce

Bertolli Alfredo Sauce

The Bertolli Alfredo Sauce is a simple yet delicious Alfredo sauce that comes in a 3/15 ounce jar, which has been smartly packaged. It contains spices and natural flavors with no added preservatives so you get a quality Alfredo sauce at hand. Many people found the taste of the Bertolli Alfredo Sauce pretty unique and cheesy, which is good if you want a cheesy type of taste for certain salads and dishes that you are going to use it on.

For instance, you can use the Bertolli Alfredo Sauce for salads involving tuna, shrimp, and even rice. Because of the no added preservative mixture, it definitely tastes like something you can make at home. The mixture isn’t bland and paste-like due to the number of spices that have been blended in.

Prego Alfredo Sauce

Prego Alfredo Sauce with Real Bacon

If you want something that has a touch of bacon, the Prego Alfredo Sauce can be a good choice. This unique Alfredo sauce has bits of bacon, which can be a great addition to taste – especially for the kids (or if you just like bacon in general). Each bottle contains 14.5 ounces of Alfredo sauce and each of them also come with peppercorn bits, other than bacon.

This kind of sauce would be useful for most meat products like turkey and hamburger, aside from salads. You can also find the Prego Alfredo Sauce useful for pasta and noodles, aside from veggie and meat salads. The bacon bits aren’t too small – you can actually taste them, and they can really add to the flavor of the Alfredo sauce for any dish.

Mario Batali Alfredo Pasta Sauce

Mario Batali Alfredo Pasta Sauce

Coming in a 15-ounce bottle, the Mario Batali Alfredo Pasta Sauce would be a good choice if your forte is Mexican cuisine. This is because of the fact that the recipe used for making this sauce is a bit spicy due to the dried red chilies, which can be a good complement to most Mexican dishes and recipes. It is full of great spices that can help you cook up a hearty meal, whether it’s Mexican or any other international dish – or even your own local ones.

Among the ingredients of the Mario Batali Alfredo Pasta Sauce include extra virgin olive oil, Romano cheese, Parmigiano-Reggiano cheese, and of course, the hot peppers. You can add it to recipes like fettuccine, ravioli, pasta and many more. It has no preservatives so it also definitely tastes homemade, to make your recipes more authentic at home.

Prego Alfredo Sauce Homestyle

Prego Alfredo Sauce, Homestyle Alfredo

A variation of our first pick would be the Prego Alfredo Sauce Homestyle, which has a more homemade taste, and still very delicious. It is comprised of parmesan cheese, fresh cream and garlic bits, which make the texture creamy, smooth and offering the right kind of Alfredo sauce flavor. Each container has 14.5 ounces, which can be enough for certain recipes in one go.

You can definitely make use of the Prego Alfredo Sauce Homestyle to make macaroni and even veggie salads out there. It has a slightly salty taste but with just the right amount of saltiness. Because of the rich and creamy consistency, making macaroni and cheese just got better. In fact, you can also make tuna recipes out of it due to the fresh taste that doesn’t feel too sticky.

Classico Asiago Romano Alfredo Sauce

Classico Asiago Romano Alfredo Sauce

A lighter Alfredo sauce mixture you can consider would be the Classico Asiago Romano Alfredo Sauce. It is made with Romano and parmesan cheese, as well as a unique cheese called Asiago. Because of the light mixture, it has significantly less fat and calories, making it ideal for people who are on a stricter diet. It is made with natural flavors so it will help you cut down on preservatives and the like – good for healthier eating.

Just because the Classico Asiago Romano Alfredo Sauce is light doesn’t mean it won’t have a good taste – the flavors are still retained despite toning down the fat and calorie content. Because of this, you can still add it to casseroles, including tuna, chicken and various salads you can think of.

McCormick Pasta Sauce Blend (Creamy Garlic Alfredo)

The McCormick Pasta Sauce Blend, coming in Creamy Garlic Alfredo, is definitely a must-have if you plan to make your own pasta or carbonara at home. Because it is made without MSG, it is healthier for you and your family due to not containing any artificial flavors. It is only made with natural spices so your mix will definitely taste homemade and authentic. Each pack contains 1.25 ounces and you can also order in bulk.

The McCormick brand has always been well-known for condiments and the like, and this is a great choice for you due to the inclusion of spices and ingredients like Parmesan and Romano cheeses and nonfat dry milk. You can use it for making fettuccine recipes and any Italian pasta dish you have in mind.

Knorr Alfredo Pasta Sauce Mix

If you are a fan of Knorr products, they also have something for your fettuccine pasta – the Knorr Alfredo Pasta Sauce Mix. Each can contains 16 ounces and you can definitely add it to various recipes, such as salads, vegetables, pizza, shrimp dishes and the like. It gives a very distinct homemade taste and can also be used for restaurants.

Because it already comes with various spices, it is easy to mix and simple to prepare Alfredo sauce mix. And because it comes in a larger canister, you can be able to use it for many recipes in bulk. Aside from that, you can also add your own spices, such as chives or garlic, to make it truly homemade in taste. It’s also a pretty budget-friendly alternative to higher priced products if you can’t afford them.

Simply Organic Alfredo Seasoning Mix

If you absolutely love organic products in the market, the Simply Organic Alfredo Seasoning Mix can be a good choice for you. It is a certified organic Alfredo sauce for those who want a natural homemade taste while retaining a delicious set of flavors. Each pack contains 1.48 ounces, in which you can buy in bulk as well (much like the McCormick one). What’s more, because of this smart packaging, you can take it with you to camping and backpacking.

Because it is made with Kosher certification and USDA approval, you can definitely be confident that it’s organic. It can be used for most pasta dishes with a cheesy and creamy feel without a lot of effort. Recipes involving fettuccine noodles can have a more organic flavor with the right amount of saltiness and buttery taste without a greasy feeling.

Jersey Italian Original Alfredo Sauce

If you want a classic mixture, the Jersey Italian Original Alfredo Sauce can be a great choice for you, being made with authentic Parmigiano-Reggiano cheese. It has been used in Italy for many years and has been the pioneer of all Alfredo sauce mixtures out there. Therefore, if you want a classic touch to your fettuccine Alfredo pasta recipe, this is definitely a considerable mixture for you.

Kids will definitely love this mix because of the authentic flavor. Because of this taste, it will make you feel like you are eating on a 5-star Italian restaurant. The sodium content is only at 90 mg so it is the very small amount that will not be too salty at all.

Stonewall Kitchen Basil Alfredo Pasta Sauce

If you want something that has a touch of basil, the Stonewall Kitchen Basil Alfredo Pasta Sauce is a cool choice for you. Each bottle has 15 ounces of Alfredo sauce, which can be a good amount to stock up in the pantry. You can use it for various recipes like pizza, pasta, and bruschetta. It has the right mix of herbs and spices to have a more distinct homemade flavor.

Herbs that are in the Stonewall Kitchen Basil Alfredo Pasta Sauce include basil and a bit of salt. It has Romano and Parmigiano Reggiano cheeses as well for the just-right Alfredo sauce flavor.

Frequently Asked Questions

To help you decide on the best store-bought Alfredo sauce, here are some frequently asked questions you may find helpful:

What can you add to Alfredo sauce to make it better?

Alfredo sauce that is store-bought can be a bit bland or not tasting well. Here is a recipe that can help to improve your Alfredo sauce. You will need the following ingredients:

  • Alfredo sauce (1 jar)
  • Red pepper, crushed (1 tbsp)
  • Cajun seasoning (1/2 tbsp)
  • Italian seasoning (1/2 tbsp)
  • Mozzarella cheese, shredded (1 cup)
  • Milk or cream/chicken stock (1 cup)
  • Parmesan cheese, grated (1/2 cup)
  • Garlic, minced (1 tbsp)

To prepare these ingredients, you can just do the following:

  1. Heat up a nonstick skillet using the medium to low heat.
  2. Put in the minced garlic onto the nonstick skillet.
  3. While the garlic cooks, add seasonings you have in mind.
  4. Add your Alfredo sauce to the mix.
  5. Mix the sauce and garlic.
  6. Little by little, add the cheese to the mix.
  7. Stir the mix slowly until you have melted the cheese.
  8. Add some more liquid and stir carefully if the cheese is too sticky.
  9. Add seasoning if you think the taste is not enough.
  10. Add any other ingredients if you wish.

What can I add to jar Alfredo sauce?

To improve the formula of your Alfredo sauce jar, here are some ingredients you can add to it:

Ground black pepper Black pepper is a common spice that can be found in most recipes. It can add a little bit of taste to any bland mixture.
Broccoli Broccoli is a healthy choice for an add-in to your jar Alfredo sauce. Broccoli is rich in vitamins and minerals that may be good for your body as well.
Garlic Garlic adds more taste and natural saltiness to your Alfredo sauce, plus it also has many health benefits such as being anti-inflammatory for a sore throat and the like.
Half and half This refers to a mix of whole milk and light cream, which is used in most kitchen recipes. You can buy them in most grocery stores.
Parmesan cheese Parmesan cheese is a kind of Italian cheese that is also called the Parmigiano-Reggiano cheese. It can be bought from stores and has a hard texture.
Cream cheese This is a kind of cheese that is a mixture of cream and milk. You can buy it from various grocery stores worldwide.
Spinach This is another beneficial vegetable, much like broccoli, and can give you a lot of vitamins and minerals, much like how it benefits Popeye.
Chicken Chicken is a healthy option, especially because it is white meat, which can benefit people who are working out and looking for protein.
Seafood Seafood needs to be thawed if it comes right from the freezer. Seafood is also rich in protein.


What can I make with a jar of Alfredo?

Common recipes you can make with a jar of Alfredo include:


  • Fettuccine Alfredo pasta
  • Chicken casserole
  • Carbonara muffins
  • Baked spaghetti
  • Cheesy scalloped potatoes


In the long run, the best store bought Alfredo sauce depends on your taste preference – do you like bacon bits or veggie bits, or do you want your sauce to be pure, so that you can add the herbs and spices yourself? It all depends on your style of cooking as to which is the best for you.


Which of these do you think is the best store bought Alfredo sauce for you? We’d like to know, so comment down below!